The key performance indicator acronym (KPI) is used so much that it has come to be associated with any type of business measure. Everything is called a KPI and it is a silly distraction from an important business tool. Not every measure is a KEY Performance Indicator, only those measures that are critically important to making a difference in the marketplace are truly KEY to your company health and performance.
Because of this confusion around Key performance indicators the wrong measurements are often used. Too often a KPI is used to measure discrete components of an organization and are frequently focused on lagging indicators.
If the KPI can not be used to steer your company, to plot course changes into the future, then they should not be called a KPI.
A proper KPI is:
- KEY to your business health (lagging) or growth (leading)
- Focused on your PERFORMANCE in the marketplace
- And an INDICATOR of your success in delivering customer value.
If your KPI does not fall into these broad categories as the “instrument panel” to keep your company on track then it is not an appropriate KPIs.
I chose those analogies carefully to line up with the 3 key business value proposition areas of process, innovation, and customer focus. The first two, the way I have defined them are more closely aligned to process and innovation while the last one is exclusively linked to the customer focus.
What Should a KPI or Key Performance Indicator Measure – What is a KPI?
A true KPI should represent an underlying business need that addresses your company’s position in the marketplace–, not a single discrete process measure as so many use them today. It should be directional in nature providing guidance to broader business activities but it is not a specific organizational performance measure. However, a good KPI will generally be an index of several organizational performance measures or, more appropriately, several goals from various organizations and activities all rolled together.
Too Many Goals are called KPIs
Many commentators, consultants, and other professionals confuse KEY Performance Indicators with more discrete goals and the metrics to support those goals. As you move further away from the top level of the KPI to address more discrete elements of operational performance you are no longer looking at KPIs. Your company does not need a KPI for every metric. In fact, the most effective KPI will generally be an index of several metrics or several departmental goals, properly weighted to correctly address marketplace competitive pressures.
Key Performance Indicator Alignment
KPIs should align with one or more of the three value proposition areas of operational excellence, customer focus, or innovation. Underneath those KPIs some of the specific goals, measures, or metrics to define top level KPIs will fall into the area of competitive pressures. How well you execute against those competitive pressures to enhance your value proposition directly affects your position in the marketplace. The KPI index of various goals and measures provide a great underlying foundation for a solid ERP, SAP, or IT business case. These various goals and metrics as well as the processes that support them become a great foundation for your ERP, SAP, or IT business case –, they are powerful for guiding IT spend and IT investment as well as corporate direction.
The components of each of the areas of competitive pressure should focus on the three business drivers: cost, revenue, and profitability. These three areas should underlay each of the metrics that are used to define your goals, and then the index of those goals and the weighting of each of those measures becomes the KPI or score for your business.
Key Performance is All About Business
One way to determine if you have created an appropriate KPI is whether it is directed at your company’s value proposition (operational excellence, customer focus, or innovation) or whether it is focused on competitive pressures (vendor / customer power, competitors, or new products / services). A solid Key Performance Indicator can be built from an index of either a value proposition element or a competitive pressure element. To develop skill with these measures you may wish to define your goals first at the competitive pressure level. As time goes on and your comfort increases you may begin to align them higher up into the value proposition area. Then each of the competitive pressures is addressed for each of the value proposition areas you wish to target.
I am a proponent of keeping the KPI at the highest level, at the level of your value proposition. However in some companies, especially those businesses or industries who deal with commodities, your KPI indexes might be better aligned more directly at the landscape of competitive pressures. Either way there is a close relationship to your value proposition and competitive pressures so either will work.
KPI, Value Proposition, Competitive Pressures, and Business Goal Alignment
It is not easy! If it were easy the whole area of strategy and KPI alignment would just be another commodity. As another commodity it wouldn’t produce results that help your business to win in the marketplace. But while it’s not easy, it is possible and like all things that take a measure of skill the more you practice it and the more diligent you are the better you get and the easier the exercise becomes.
- align vendor kpi